16th November 2026

When belief is presented as truth: Why evidence-based justice matters in cases of sexual violence

9 min read

In November 2026, British comedian, actor and former television presenter Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison following his conviction for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault. His conviction has prompted renewed public discussion about sexual violence, accountability and the justice system, while igniting another narrative: the portrayal of the accused as a persecuted truth-seeker, a victim of an establishment seeking to silence him, and a martyr of a justice system supposedly working against him.

The public response to Brand’s conviction follows a pattern we have seen in other cases involving powerful public figures around the world. When someone has built an identity around challenging established institutions, that persona can shape how supporters interpret the allegations made against them while those who came forward are treated with suspicion and their accounts become the subject of public debate. In Brand’s case, this framing has helped turn a criminal conviction into a story about persecution and martyrdom. It is a harrowing example of how personal belief systems can be used to discredit survivors and reinforce the myths and stereotypes that undermine accountability in sexual violence cases.

Truth should be linked to evidence, not beliefs alone

There is an important distinction here between “truth” and belief. People are entitled to question institutions, scrutinise the media and hold justice systems accountable. When a narrative is built around what people already believe about an individual, evidence that challenges those beliefs can be treated as further proof of a conspiracy. In this way, the idea of a search for truth can itself be used to undermine accountability.

This matters particularly in cases of sexual violence, where harmful myths and stereotypes have long influenced how allegations are understood.  We are accustomed to seeing these myths directed at survivors: they must have wanted it because of what they wore, how much they drank, their prior relationship with the accused, or because they did not physically resist. 

To be clear, a survivor’s testimony is evidence. It must be assessed fairly alongside other relevant evidence, without assumptions about how someone experiencing sexual violence should behave.

But rape myths can also operate through the way we interpret the accused person’s behaviour, status and public identity. A famous or influential man can be portrayed as incapable of committing sexual violence, or as the target of an institutional conspiracy, while the people who report harm are cast as unreliable, opportunistic or motivated by something other than seeking justice. These harmful narratives shift attention away from the evidence and towards assumptions about who deserves to be believed.

Evidence-based justice needs institutional backing

One example in practice involves an injunction that came to light after Brand’s conviction, further highlighting how legal mechanisms can also become barriers to reporting and seeking support. In 2015, the High Court issued an injunction against Szilvia Berki, who had separately accused Brand of assaulting her in 2014. According to documents published by Tax Policy Associates, the final injunction prohibited her from discussing the alleged incident with journalists, friends and family, and, on its face, prevented her from speaking to the police. She was also ordered to pay £50,000 in legal costs.

The court decided the harassment claim without determining whether the alleged assault occurred, and Brand’s subsequent convictions do not establish what happened in this separate case. The injunction itself, however, highlights additional concerns about how an order intended to prevent harassment could impose such far-reaching restrictions on someone’s ability to speak about an alleged assault. In September 2026, a Court of Appeal judge acknowledged concerns about the order’s breadth but declined to reopen an earlier refusal of permission to appeal, indicating that the appropriate route was to apply to the High Court to vary the injunction.

This example calls for scrutiny of the legal processes and professional decisions involved. Were the imposed restrictions necessary and proportionate? How can institutions ensure that legal mechanisms are not used in ways that prevent people from reporting alleged violence or seeking support? 

We believe that establishing consistent standards to process sexual violence cases is essential to remedy these differences, a topic that has been debated publicly for years. In England and Wales, where Brand was convicted, this debate has been brought out in the House of Lords’ discussion on 9 November 2026 about whether jury directions on harmful myths and stereotypes should be mandatory in rape and serious sexual offence trials. Judges can already give directions to address rape myths, tailored to the circumstances of each case. But the November discussion raised concerns that, while many judges follow best practice, this does not happen consistently. 

Challenging rape myths and assumptions about survivor behaviour cannot depend solely on the knowledge or beliefs of individuals. It requires clear standards, appropriate training and institutional commitment to ensuring that beliefs do not undermine how justice can be delivered.

For lawyers, prosecutors, investigators and other professionals working in the justice system, thorough investigations of sexual violence already require professionals to navigate complex evidence, deeply entrenched stereotypes and institutional barriers. High-profile cases add another dimension: the prospect of public backlash, reputational attacks and accusations of political bias. When a case attracts intense attention, professionals may face considerable pressure simply for pursuing an investigation or reaching an outcome that challenges the public’s expectations. 

This is why the distinction between impartiality and public approval matters. An evidence-based investigation does not endorse an allegation; it is a necessity for access to justice. A survivor-centred approach means ensuring that evidence is assessed by examining the actions of the perpetrator without allowing assumptions about the survivor to determine the outcome. The same standards of scrutiny must apply regardless of the accused person’s wealth, influence, reputation or public following.

Ultimately, justice cannot depend on whether the public likes the person bringing an allegation forward or the person accused of committing a crime. The justice system must be grounded in evidence, established legal standards and due process. That requires institutions to support the professionals responsible for investigating and prosecuting sexual violence, particularly when cases attract hostility or intense public scrutiny. 

Brand’s sentencing is an important example of what is possible when a case proceeds through the justice system. It does not mean that the wider culture of victim-blaming and impunity has disappeared. The backlash against those who came forward demonstrates how much work remains. Consent should never be assumed, and responsibility for sexual violence should always lie with the perpetrator. Ensuring that this principle is reflected in law and in practice requires proper implementation of consent-based laws to ensure professionals are equipped and supported in carrying out their responsibilities without prejudice or fear of reputational consequences.

When narratives compete to define the truth, the justice system’s responsibility is to establish the facts. That responsibility should never be determined by power, public opinion or the popularity of the person accused.

Newsletter Sign-up

Make a donation

I want to donate